Quality Function Deployment
Linking a Company with Its Customers

Ronald G. Day

Quality Function Deployment: Linking a Company with Its Customers Ronald G. Day
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Day, Ronald G.
Quality function deployment: linking a company with its customers / Ronald G. Day
Includes bibliographical references and index.
ISBN0-87389-202-X (alk. paper)
1. Quality function deployment. 2. Production management—Quality control. 3. New products—Management. I. Title. TS156.D387 1993, 658.5!62—dc20 93-4479 CIP, © 1993 by ASQC
Acquisitions Editor: Susan Westergard Production Editor: Annette Wall Marketing Administrator: Mark Olson Set in Times by Montgomery Media, Inc. Cover design by Montgomery Media, Inc. Printed and bound by BookCrafters, Inc.
ASQC Mission: To facilitate continuous improvement and increase customer satisfaction by identifying, communicating, and promoting the use of quality principles, concepts, and technologies; and thereby be recognized throughout the world as the leading authority on, and champion for, quality.
For a free copy of the ASQC Quality Press Publications Catalog, including ASQC membership information, call 800-248-1946., Printed in the United States of America
ASQC, Quality Press, 611 East Wisconsin Avenue, Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53202

Contents

Preface

Acknowledgments


1 The Quality Function Deployment (QFD) Concept

Linking a Company with Its Customers
Tools and Concepts for Improving the Business
The Proactive Versus the Reactive Approach
Defining QFD
The Relationship of QFD to Other Quality and Engineering Tools
Defining Quality
QFD and the Product Development Process

2 An Overview of the QFD Process

The Objective of the QFD Process
Understanding the QFD Matrix Concept
The Two Primary Parts of the QFD Matrix
  The Customer Portion
  The Technical Portion
An Overview Flowchart of the QFD Process

3 The Voice of the Customer

Determining Which People to Survey
Obtaining the Voice of the Customer
Understanding the Voice
Handling the Voice
Organizing the Voices into Natural Groups
Obtaining Additional Customer Information

4 Developing a QFD Matrix: The Customer Information Portion

A Team Process
Developing the Customer Information Table
Using the Customer Information Table as a Preplanning Chart
Using the Preplanning Chart for Project Management and Priority Item Selection

5 Developing a QFD Matrix: The Technical Information Portion

Translating Customer Voices into Technical Requirements
Recording the Team Decisions for Technical Requirements
Determining Relationships
Direction of Improvement
Competitive Technical Data
Establishing Targets
Co-relationships
Other Possible Matrix Entries
  Other Voices
  Field Experience
  Column Weights

6 Reviewing the Matrix for Priority Items

Analysis of the Customer Information Portion of the Matrix
Establishing Priorities
Balancing Resources: Establishing Action Plans
Technical Specifications

7 Deployment to Subsequent Levels: Part Deployment

Determining the Inputs to the Matrix
The Need for a Concept Selection Process
A Concept Selection Process
Examining the Causes of Potential Failure
Completing the Part Planning Matrix
Analyzing the Completed Matrix

8 Deployment to Subsequent Levels: Process Deployment

Determining the Inputs to the Matrix
The Need for a Concept Selection Process
Determining the Critical Process Requirements
Completing the Matrix

9 Deployment to Subsequent Levels: Manufacturing Deployment

The Row of Information Through the Organization
Typical Manufacturing Planning

10 Putting It All Together

The Customer Information Matrix
Adding the Technical Matrix Information
A Research and Development Matrix
Determining the Best Concept
The Part Planning Matrix
The Process Planning Matrix
Manufacturing Planning

11 Differing Levels of Customer Voices

Using Matrices for First- and Second-Tier Suppliers
Using the Concept for Innovations: Unknown Customers

12 Controlling Inputs to the Matrix

Presorting and Combining Voices
Use of the Preplanning Chart
Using the Affinity Diagram Process

13 Ancillary Matrices with Potential Value

A Matrix of Voices Versus Functions
A Research and Development Matrix
Continuous Processing Applications

14 Using the QFD Concept in Business Planning: An Overview

The Deployment of a Business Plan
Objectives Versus Strategies
Strategies Versus Action Plans
Action Plan Reviews

15 Using the QFD Process in Business Planning: A Detailed Examination

Determining the Key Points of the Vision Statement
Vision Statements and Their Associated Objectives
Conducting a Sanity Check
Developing Strategies
Developing Strategy Weights
Objectives and Strategies
Strategies and Action Plans
Surveying Customers and Employees
Responsibilities and Reviews

16 Other Possible Applications for the Matrix

A Planning Matrix
Problem Solution
Service Sector Applications
The Matrix as a Checklist
A Matrix of Technical Requirements Versus Test Requirements

17 Organizing Teams and Planning QFD Projects

Developing the Team and Team Guidelines
Planning the Project
Meetings, Assignments, and Project Selection
Making the QFD Process an Integral Part of the Product Development Process

References

Index

Preface

The author's experience over many years in industry has served as a constant reminder that most companies have not made an aggressive effort to understand their customers' wants and needs. Many companies depend on their warranty programs, customer complaints, and inputs from their sales staffs to keep them in touch with their customers. The result is a focus on what is wrong with the existing product with little or no focus on what the customer wants and expects in new product offerings. Furthermore, without the benefit of customer surveys, companies have little idea about how customers rate their company and how they rate the performance of their competitors. In these companies, new products are planned and brought to market without a real firsthand knowledge of the potential customers' wants and needs. Simple logic says that products designed without knowledge of the potential customers' requirements will frequently fail to satisfy their needs. Sales will not meet their potential. Competitors who listen to the customer and bring out products that respond to their needs will compete more effectively and gain market share.

The methodology of quality function deployment (QFD) employs the customers' wants and needs as its basic input. It was this aspect of QFD that first attracted the author's attention to the process. If companies could be encouraged to use QFD as a methodology during product development, it would force them to listen to their customers. Thus, for the first time, many companies would be put in touch with existing and prospective customers and the knowledge gained would help them develop more competitive, state-of-the-art products for their markets. This is the aspect of QFD that continues to hold the author's attention—it is a process that puts companies in touch with their customers and helps them develop products that are more customer oriented and responsive. It is a process to increase competitiveness and develop a base of satisfied customers. For many industries threatened by global competition, this level of customer focus and response is necessary for survival.

This is a pragmatic book. It is intended as a guide for practitioners. It captures much of the pertinent experience gained during the last 8 years since the author first investigated and started working with the concept. It is intended to give users an insight into the use of the QFD matrix in a variety of applications. It presents the author's experience and ideas on how to handle some of the typical problems experienced in using the QFD matrix concept.

QFD was introduced to the United States in the early 1980s. Several articles and translations of Japanese examples appeared shortly after its introduction which were based largely on observations of Japanese applications.

The American Supplier Institute (ASI) in Dearborn, Michigan, and GOAL/QPC in Methuen, Massachusetts, have been the primary organizations offering an overview and workshop-type training since that time. Beginning in 1989, ASI and GOAL/QPC have jointly sponsored annual seminars to update the level of QFD knowledge.

The recent emphasis on company-wide processes to improve internal operations and competitiveness has caused many companies to examine the ideas of total quality management, the ISO 9000 standards, and the Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award requirements. Many companies have been introduced to the importance of knowing their customer through their investigation of these company-wide program concepts.

Typically, as the QFD experience has increased and the knowledge base has expanded, many new ideas and approaches have emerged for handling the data and numerical portions of the matrix. Software has been developed to facilitate the construction of QFD matrices. This process of exploration and refinement will continue, as it does in all disciplines.

The real challenge, however, is a much more pragmatic one. American companies still need to come to grips with the fact that they must be in touch with their customers, that they must fund programs for customer research, and that the process must be a continual one. They must use some organized method to examine these customers' wants and needs and translate them into action within their companies. This is the challenge. It is the intent and purpose of this book to explore issues germane to this focus.

The examples used in the book are generic. They are based on the experience of many companies. Companies that have invested funds to determine the "voice" of their customers typically find a number of issues that are important to their customers and that they will incorporate into their next product developments. From a competitive viewpoint, the opportunity offered through this customer knowledge would be lost if it were published. In recognition of the confidential and proprietary nature of every QFD study, the information and data used in this book have been altered substantially. Some examples were developed strictly to help enhance an understanding of certain aspects of the process.

One of the principal ideas behind this book is to provide insight into the use of QFD in nonproduct applications. The author believes there is a major opportunity for application in these areas and hopes that this text will encourage people to investigate this potential.